A Storytelling Coach More details here: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ravishankar-iyer/
Welcome to the 98th edition of 'Story Rules on Saturday'.
This week's flagship article - by Ben Thompson of Stratechery - is about how to deal with AI-generated homework.
a. AI Homework by Ben Thompson (Stratechery)
Is ChatGPT the end of the school essay?
Some schools seem to think so and are taking drastic steps:
Amidst this apocalyptic reaction, Ben Thompson has a thoughtful take on the whole Chat GPT revolution.
I've summarised his article in three messages.
1. Generative AI can make mistakes
So Ben asks a question to ChatGPT regarding a school homework for his daughter - and the AI gets it wrong!
Ben writes (emphasis mine):
In short: ChatGPT relies on the internet for its answers and the internet is... not exactly a paragon for 100% truth and accuracy. And so, one should not take responses from ChatGPT as God's edict.
2. These mistakes can creep in because ChatGPT uses a probabilistic (and not deterministic) approach to answering questions
I liked the framing shared by Ben about the two types of approaches - deterministic and probabilistic - to find answers:
4,839 + 3,948 - 45
you get 8,742
, every time. That’s also why it is a sufficient remedy for teachers to requires students show their work: there is one path to the right answer and demonstrating the ability to walk down that path is more important than getting the final result.
(For instance, if you ask ChatGPT what are the first 10 prime numbers)
Another way to look at it: ChatGPT is a master at reasoning by analogy, not by first principles (as yet).
3. Use the tools but not on a blind trust basis; verify and edit the responses for yourself
The implication from this piece - don't blindly take ChatGPT responses and run with it. Just like you cannot cite the first Google search result as your answer for a crucial business question, you will need to verify the responses given by ChatGPT.
Ben shares an extract from a fascinating article by Noah Smith and roon, titled 'Generative AI - Autocomplete for everything', which summarises the way to work with generative AI:
This above piece has an evocative thought, which I paraphrase like this: Generative AI (like many other disruptive technologies before it) will not eliminate jobs. It will eliminate tasks. The freed up time can be used by humans to become more productive at their work and move on to higher-order tasks.
Finally, Ben's advice to teachers - allow students to work with generative AI tools, but with a twist:
In sum:
So net-net, two skills that become super important with the advent of AI-research technologies:
- Asking the right questions and prompts
- Verifying and editing the response before sharing
b. Teach Skills not Facts by Melanie Trecek-King
In this article, science teacher Melanie Trecek-King shares some of her experience about how science should be taught.
She shares this quote by Carl Sagan:
Many folks (like me) may not have enjoyed science in school. But we loved Bill Bryson's science book "A Short History of Nearly Everything". In that book, Bryson delves into the context, the characters and the crazy circumstances that led to various scientific breakthroughs. Watching the story of science discoveries unfold before your eyes makes them come out alive.
Unfortunately most schools are still in the business making their students cram facts:
In the rest of the piece, Melanie describes a new course that she launched in her institution that "focuses less on the findings of science and almost exclusively on science literacy and critical thinking".
Here's how Melanie sums it up:
a. Creators, Creativity, and Technology with Bob Iger
In 2019, one studio absolutely dominated the US box office. You could call it the most valuable storytelling-company in the world.
An interesting fact: In the list above, except for The Lion King, which was an original Disney animation franchise, all the others were from companies that Disney had acquired in the past 14 years:
- Marvel with the Avengers series
- Pixar with its animated hits, and
- Lucasfilm with the Star Wars movies
There was one guy responsible for all those successful acquisitions (and most importantly integrations): Bob Iger.
Iger had headed Disney from 2005 to 2020, a period in which it completed these massive acquisitions. Incidentally, after leaving Disney in 2020, Iger was called back to head it in November 2022.
In this conversation with the VC firm a16z, Iger talks about how he navigated these major buyouts, how he tackled the innovator's dilemma and most importantly, how did he manage creative talent, especially that of acquired companies. (Mostly by staying out of the way).
Listen to the conversation for a masterclass in how to manage creative talent.
(In case interested, you can check out his book - 'The Ride of a Lifetime: Lessons in Creative Leadership from 15 Years as CEO of the Walt Disney Company' which released in 2019)
A fascinating thread on the history of art... and why it's not necessarily a bad sign that today's art seems pale in comparison with what was created during the European Renaissance. Also, why the movies of today are a great place to look for modern-day art.
I just LOVE these remarkable map-charts by 'Stats of India' which shows the population of various Indian states by city/town:
The 'Consulting Comedy' Twitter handle is just hilarious :D
"A computer would deserve to be called intelligent if it could deceive a human into believing that it was human."
- Alan Turing
a. Kevin Hart's Guide to Black History (Netflix)
I came across this while browsing Netflix for something to watch with my 10-year old... and was pleasantly surprised.
Kevin Hart, the Hollywood star and stand-up comic has created a fun 1-hour sketch comedy take on the history of key Black American heroes. Heroes whose names go beyond the known ones of Martin Luther King and Harriet Tubman.
What is special is Kevin's kid-friendly comic approach to telling their stories. The tales are educational, yet vastly entertaining. My son was guffawing at some of the silly jokes.
I'd love to see something like this made for lesser-known Indian heroes.
a. Honest Trailers - RRR by Screen Junkies (5:39)
Honest Trailers is a brilliant concept where the creators make a revised, 'honest' trailer that does a hilarious take on what actually makes the movie worth watching. It is brutal in its takedown of any pompous or illogical elements of the movie; and yet manages to give credit where it's due.
With RRR being the flavour of the season, this video is a superb take on what makes the movie special (and unintentionally hilarious).
As my friend Ananth said, watch out for that line about the in-laws :)
That's it folks: my recommended reads, listens and views for the week.
Take care and stay safe.
Ravi
PS: Got this email as a forward? Get your own copy here.
Access this email on a browser or share this email on Whatsapp, LinkedIn or Twitter. You can access the archive of previous posts here.
You are getting this email as a part of the 'Story Rules on Saturday' Newsletter. To get your own copy, sign up here.
A Storytelling Coach More details here: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ravishankar-iyer/
Welcome to the sixty-first edition of '3-2-1 by Story Rules'. A newsletter recommending good examples of storytelling across: 3 tweets 2 articles, and 1 long-form content piece Let's dive in. 𝕏 3 Tweets of the week Source: X My son keeps trying to convince me to read more fiction. Maybe he should use this argument. Source: X Such a brilliant pic! Source: X Ok, this is wildly inappropriate stereotyping, but you gotta admit it's funny! 📄 2 Articles of the week a. 'It's not so terribly strange...
Welcome to the sixtieth edition of '3-2-1 by Story Rules'. A newsletter recommending good examples of storytelling across: 3 tweets 2 articles, and 1 long-form content piece Let's dive in. 𝕏 3 Tweets of the week Source: X I think everyone - not just entrepreneurs - should study philosophy. (Reid Hoffman is the founder of LinkedIn) Source: X Heartwarming example! Also great to see medical facilities in India realise the importance of better communication with patients. Source: X This is super...
Welcome to the fifty-ninth edition of '3-2-1 by Story Rules'. A newsletter recommending good examples of storytelling across: 3 tweets 2 articles, and 1 long-form content piece Let's dive in. 𝕏 3 Tweets of the week Source: X This would be a great resource for authentic data on India. Source: X I saw this statistic in the Indus Valley 2024 Report too - Indian corporates need to up their R&D spend! Source: X Don't wait for inspiration to begin writing. 📄 2 Articles of the week a. 'Selling...